US Court Sends Summonses to NSA Ajit Doval, Ex-RAW Chief in Pannun Lawsuit

Exterior of a formal district court building in New Delhi
Photo: AI-generated illustration

A United States federal court has sent summonses naming National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) chief Samant Goel in a civil lawsuit filed by Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, the Press Trust of India reported, cited by Scroll.in. The summonses were sent for service through Indian courts in New Delhi.

PTI reported that a clerk of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York confirmed the summonses were dispatched by courier last Friday to three district court complexes in the capital: Patiala House, Tis Hazari and Dwarka. US civil procedure allows service abroad through a receiving country’s own courts when a defendant cannot be reached directly, which is the route Pannun’s lawyers are now using to reach Doval and Goel in India.

Pannun, a US and Canadian citizen who serves as general counsel of Sikhs for Justice, an organisation India banned in 2019, filed the civil suit alleging an attempt on his life. India designated Pannun an individual terrorist under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act in 2020.

The underlying case

Pannun’s lawsuit accuses Doval of orchestrating a plot, allegedly involving an Indian intelligence agency, to have him killed on US soil. His suit seeks damages from Doval and Goel personally, naming both men in their individual capacities rather than as representatives of the Indian state.

The allegation traces back to a separate criminal case. Praman News reported last week that Indian national Nikhil Gupta pleaded guilty in February to conspiring to kill Pannun, allegedly on the instructions of an Indian government employee. A superseding indictment named Gupta’s handler as Vikash Yadav, a former RAW officer whom US prosecutors said worked with India’s Cabinet Secretariat and directed Gupta from India. Yadav was charged separately and remains at large.

Gupta himself was sentenced on November 20 by US District Judge Victor Marrero in Manhattan to 235 months, about 19 years and seven months, after pleading guilty to conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. He will serve no supervised release because he is expected to be deported once his term ends.

How the summons reached Delhi

The latest step follows an earlier one in October, when the US State Department formally served summonses on the Indian government through India’s embassy in Washington, DC, PTI reported. This week’s filing moves the process to the Indian court system, where the summonses must still be formally served on Doval and Goel as individuals.

Neither Doval’s office nor Goel has issued a personal response to the summonses, according to the report. Service on a sitting National Security Adviser through a foreign civil court is highly unusual, and it is not yet clear whether Indian courts will process the documents given New Delhi’s position that the underlying claims are baseless.

India’s response

New Delhi has consistently denied involvement and rejected the lawsuit. On November 10, Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal called the allegations against Indian officials “fabricated and malicious,” and said any judicial documents intended for the government must be routed through the Ministry of Law and Justice, PTI reported.

In September, Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri had already dismissed Pannun’s allegations as entirely unwarranted and unsubstantiated, according to the report. India’s Ministry of External Affairs has said Yadav is no longer a government employee, and the Ministry of Home Affairs said in January that a government inquiry committee had recommended legal action against an unnamed individual, without naming Yadav directly.

Frequently asked questions

Who is Gurpatwant Singh Pannun? A US and Canadian citizen who serves as general counsel of Sikhs for Justice, a Khalistan-advocacy group banned in India since 2019. India designated him an individual terrorist under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act in 2020.

What is Pannun’s civil lawsuit about? It accuses National Security Adviser Ajit Doval of orchestrating a plot to kill him and seeks damages from Doval and former RAW chief Samant Goel personally.

How does this connect to the Nikhil Gupta case? Gupta, sentenced on November 20 to 235 months in the related criminal case, pleaded guilty to conspiring to kill Pannun on the alleged instructions of an Indian government employee, a case prosecutors say Yadav directed from India.

What has India said? India’s government has repeatedly denied involvement, calling Pannun’s civil suit against Doval and Goel fabricated and malicious, and says any court documents must be routed through its Ministry of Law and Justice.

What happens next

For the summonses to take legal effect, they must be formally served on Doval and Goel through the Delhi court system, a process India’s government has not committed to facilitating given its position that the case is baseless. How Indian authorities respond to the district courts named in the filings, and whether India’s government intervenes to block service, will determine whether the US civil case can proceed against the two named officials.

Source: Press Trust of India, via Scroll.in.