The Ministry of External Affairs on Tuesday rejected Gurpatwant Singh Pannun’s civil lawsuit against National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former RAW chief Samant Goel as “fabricated and malicious,” a day after a US federal judge allowed Pannun to attempt serving the two officials through Indian courts under the Hague Service Convention.
Pannun, general counsel of the US-banned Sikhs for Justice and a US-Canadian citizen designated an “individual terrorist” under Indian law in 2020, sued the Government of India, Doval and Goel in September 2024 in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York. The suit accuses Indian intelligence officials of directing a 2023 plot to assassinate him on American soil.
That allegation is built on the same facts behind a separate US criminal case against Indian national Nikhil Gupta, whose alleged handler, Vikash Yadav, US officials say worked out of India’s Cabinet Secretariat, which houses the Research and Analysis Wing. Gupta pleaded guilty earlier this year to conspiring to kill Pannun on the instructions of an Indian government employee, according to Scroll.in.
In February 2026, Gupta pleaded guilty in the criminal case to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering, according to Outlook India. The Ministry of External Affairs had said in October 2024 that Yadav was no longer a government employee, the same report noted.
What the US State Department confirmed
The US State Department said in a statement that a diplomatic note was signed on September 30, 2026, and delivered on October 9, 2026, serving the summons and complaint on the Government of India through its embassy in Washington, DC, the Press Trust of India reported via The Tribune.
The department added that it was legally required to transmit the documents and was not taking a position on the merits of Pannun’s case, per the same PTI report.
The State Department separately informed the Southern District of New York of the delivery in a letter dated October 20, 2026, which was filed with the court on October 28, according to Outlook India. That letter did not state a position on whether Pannun had met every requirement for serving a foreign government under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, the report said.
What the court ruled on serving Doval and Goel
Separately, US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla ruled that Pannun can attempt to serve Doval and Goel through Indian courts under Article 19 of the Hague Service Convention, American Bazaar reported. Earlier attempts, through India’s designated central authority, an email to India’s attorney general, and service via a lawyer representing Yadav in his criminal case, had all been rejected by the court.
Pannun must submit a proposed service packet to the court by November 30, after which the court clerk would forward the documents to the identified Indian courts. American Bazaar’s report notes the order is a procedural decision on how papers may be delivered, not a finding on the underlying allegations against either official.
What India said
Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal told a press briefing on Tuesday that India rejects the “fabricated and malicious attacks on our high officials,” according to PTI, calling the lawsuits frivolous. He said a request to serve judicial documents inside India can only be routed through the country’s designated central authority, the Ministry of Law and Justice, not through a foreign court’s order served via diplomatic note.
New Delhi has previously set up an internal high-level committee to examine US findings related to the case and has repeatedly denied government involvement in any plot against Pannun. Indian Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri had earlier called Pannun’s allegations “completely unwarranted” and unsubstantiated.
What happens next
Pannun’s deadline to file his proposed service plan with the Southern District of New York is November 30. Whether Indian courts will act on a referral that New Delhi’s own foreign ministry says does not follow the correct channel remains unresolved, and no hearing date has been set for the underlying lawsuit.
The case’s next concrete marker is that November 30 filing. What India’s judiciary does, or does not do, with a US court’s referral it has already called procedurally improper is the question to watch.
Frequently asked questions
Does this mean Ajit Doval has been formally served?
No. Judge Failla’s ruling only clears a route, through Indian courts under the Hague Service Convention, for Pannun to attempt service. Pannun still has to file a proposed service packet by November 30, and India’s Ministry of External Affairs has already said such requests must go through the Ministry of Law and Justice.
What is Pannun’s case actually about?
Pannun, a US-Canadian citizen and general counsel of the banned Sikhs for Justice, is suing the Government of India, Ajit Doval and Samant Goel for damages, alleging they directed a 2023 plot to assassinate him in the United States, the same underlying facts behind Nikhil Gupta’s separate criminal murder-for-hire case.
Has India accepted the US court’s jurisdiction?
No. The Ministry of External Affairs has called the lawsuit “fabricated and malicious” and “frivolous,” and maintains that any judicial document meant for service inside India must be routed through its own designated central authority, not delivered via a foreign court’s order.
Leave a Reply