The Madhya Pradesh High Court has quashed a police officer’s 2024 dismissal after finding the state government’s defence relied on a Supreme Court judgment that does not exist, one that court records show was generated using artificial intelligence tools.
The case involved Piyush Mani Tiwari, a former sub-inspector who was dismissed from the Madhya Pradesh Police in May 2024 after a woman cleaner at the police headquarters in Bhopal accused him of inappropriate behaviour. Tiwari challenged the dismissal, arguing he was removed without a show-cause notice, a chargesheet, or any departmental inquiry, according to a report in Scroll.in.
In defending the dismissal before the High Court, the state government cited a purported Supreme Court judgment, State of Andhra Pradesh vs. SS Mohammad Nisar, giving the citation “(2008) 5 SCC 230.” Justice Vivek Kumar Singh’s bench found no such judgment exists. The same citation number actually belongs to an unrelated case, Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu Sharma vs. State (NCT of Delhi), which concerns the suspension of a sentence in a criminal appeal.
What the court said
The court traced the fabricated citation to the use of an AI drafting tool by the state’s side, and did not treat the error lightly. Justice Singh said the court was “constrained to take serious note of the callous and irresponsible manner” in which the reply was drafted, according to Scroll.in’s report of the order.
The order said the respondents had “blindly resorted to the use of artificial intelligence tools,” and that inserting fictitious case law “borders on actively misleading the court.” The report does not quote any response from the state government to the finding.
What happens to Tiwari now
The High Court quashed Tiwari’s dismissal order and directed the state to reinstate him. The ruling does not close the matter for good. The court left it open for the state to start a regular departmental inquiry into the original complaint against him, this time following due process.
Scroll.in’s report does not mention any penalty imposed on the state or its counsel over the fabricated citation, and no further hearing date has been reported in connection with the AI-citation finding itself.
Part of a wider pattern of AI-fabricated citations in Indian courts
Madhya Pradesh’s case is not the first time an Indian court has flagged AI-generated fake case law this year. The Supreme Court separately took up a case where a trial court in Andhra Pradesh had relied on an advocate-commissioner’s report citing judgments that turned out to be non-existent and AI-generated, according to a report by OrissaPost.
In that case, a bench of Justices P S Narasimha and Alok Aradhe said a decision based on fake judgments would amount to misconduct rather than a simple decision-making error, and would carry legal consequences. The court issued notice to Attorney General R Venkataramani and Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, and appointed senior advocate Shyam Divan to assist it, OrissaPost reported.
Whether Madhya Pradesh’s state law department changes its drafting process, or whether other High Courts issue similar warnings, will be the next thing to watch as more AI-assisted filings reach Indian courtrooms.



Leave a Reply