UK Government Forced to Disclose Secret Apple Backdoor Order

Aerial view of Apple Park, Apple's corporate headquarters in Cupertino, California
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Daniel L. Lu (dllu), CC BY-SA 4.0

The UK’s Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on Thursday that the British government must confirm it issued a secret Apple backdoor order demanding authorities get access to encrypted customer data, rejecting the Home Office’s claim that disclosure would harm national security. Liberty, the rights group that brought the legal challenge, called it the first known time the government has been compelled to confirm such an order exists.

The order is a “technical capabilities notice,” a legal instrument issued under strict non-disclosure rules that barred Apple from acknowledging it publicly even after details leaked to the media roughly a year ago. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal’s ruling came after Liberty challenged the secrecy on behalf of two individuals, and it rejected the Home Office’s position that even confirming the order’s existence would compromise security.

The Home Office has not confirmed the order exists and did not respond to a request for comment reported by TechCrunch. Apple also did not comment following the ruling.

What the secret order demanded

TechCrunch reported that the order, as first described when details leaked about a year ago, originally demanded Apple build a backdoor letting UK authorities access encrypted customer data belonging to users anywhere in the world, not just in Britain. Apple refused.

The government later narrowed the demand to cover only the encrypted cloud data of British nationals, according to the same reporting. Apple challenged that narrowed version as well, and the scope of the dispute is part of what the tribunal’s Thursday ruling now forces into the open.

Why the ruling matters

Governments issuing technical capabilities notices under the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act are not normally required to confirm their existence at all, let alone in response to a legal challenge. Liberty says Thursday’s ruling breaks that pattern for the first time on record.

The case has drawn attention outside Britain too. US Senator Ron Wyden led a bipartisan letter to the Investigatory Powers Tribunal’s president in March 2025 urging that hearings on Apple’s challenge be held in public, arguing it was in the public interest to do so and that the order impeded Congress’s own oversight role. Lawmakers and officials in the US have argued that a backdoor built for UK authorities would put the privacy of Apple users in other countries, including Americans, at risk as well, since encrypted systems do not recognize national borders once breached.

Apple’s response

Rather than comply with the original order, Apple withdrew Advanced Data Protection, its end-to-end iCloud encryption feature, for new UK users in February 2025 rather than weaken it on the government’s terms. Apple spokesperson Fred Sainz said at the time that the company could no longer offer the feature in Britain and that it was gravely disappointed by the outcome. Existing UK users were told they would eventually have to turn the feature off, while the setting remained available everywhere else. Advanced Data Protection is an opt-in setting that extends end-to-end encryption to iCloud categories such as photos, notes and device backups; health data, iCloud messages and payment information are encrypted by default for all users regardless of the setting, and features like iMessage and FaceTime were not affected by the withdrawal.

Apple has repeatedly said it has “never built a backdoor or master key” to any of its products, a position the company maintained throughout the dispute without confirming or denying the specific UK order until Thursday’s tribunal ruling forced the issue into public view. James Baker of the Open Rights Group criticized the Home Office’s original demand at the time, arguing it left Britons more exposed to criminals, while cryptographer Matthew Green of Johns Hopkins University said the withdrawal made the case for wider encryption adoption elsewhere harder to enforce.

What happens next

A final tribunal hearing on exactly which details of the order can be made public is expected in 2027. Until then, the core technical demands inside the notice, and how far the narrowed version actually reaches, remain undisclosed even though the order’s existence no longer is.

Frequently asked questions

What did the UK government actually order Apple to do?
Reports describe a demand for Apple to build a backdoor giving UK authorities access to encrypted customer data, originally worldwide and later narrowed to British nationals’ data, though the exact technical scope has not been made public.

Has the UK government confirmed the order exists?
The tribunal ruling compels the government to confirm it, but as of publication the Home Office itself has not issued its own public confirmation or comment.

Did Apple build the backdoor?
No. Apple refused and instead withdrew its Advanced Data Protection encryption feature for UK users rather than comply.

Source: Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruling; TechCrunch.