Attorney General R Venkataramani has consented to criminal contempt proceedings against advocate Pravin Singhal, two days after Singhal told Chief Justice of India Surya Kant in open court that he “cannot sit in that chair.” The Supreme Court Bar Association’s petition is listed for hearing on Wednesday.
What Happened in Court
Singhal appeared before a bench of Chief Justice Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana on Monday, seeking an urgent hearing on a matter he linked to alleged judicial corruption. He told the court he had submitted papers to the Chief Justice’s office on November 2 and received no response, according to Bar and Bench‘s report on the hearing.
When the Chief Justice asked him to wait, Singhal refused and questioned Kant’s suitability for the post, telling him he “cannot sit in that chair,” before adding that he lacked the integrity for the office. The court’s audio-video feed was switched off shortly afterward, and security personnel escorted Singhal out of the courtroom.
Why the Attorney General’s Consent Matters
The Supreme Court Bar Association had asked the Attorney General to approve criminal contempt proceedings against Singhal. Under the Contempt of Courts Act, a private party cannot move a criminal contempt petition on its own, it first needs the written consent of the Attorney General or a Solicitor General. In a letter dated November 17 to SCBA secretary Pragya Baghel, Venkataramani granted that consent, describing Singhal’s conduct and remarks as “extremely scandalous and unpardonable” and saying they warranted action for criminal contempt, per Bar and Bench.
SCBA office-bearers told the bench on Tuesday that they held video recordings of Singhal making similar remarks on other occasions. Secretary Baghel and joint secretary Meenesh Dubey also asked that the fresh proceedings be tagged with an existing contempt case the SCBA has pursued against journalist Nikhil Wagle and Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut over separate remarks about the Chief Justice and the judiciary.
Part of a Wider Pattern Around the Chief Justice’s Office
Singhal’s case is the latest in a run of contempt matters tied to remarks about Chief Justice Kant since he took office. The Attorney General had already granted consent for the SCBA’s separate contempt case against Wagle and Raut over their own comments on the Chief Justice, and the Supreme Court has also issued a contempt notice to Kerala Congress office-bearers over a social media post targeting Kant. None of these matters, including Singhal’s, has resulted in a contempt finding so far, consent is only the first procedural step and is not itself a verdict.
What Happens Next
The SCBA’s petition against Singhal is listed for hearing on Wednesday, November 18. Criminal contempt of court in India can draw a fine or up to six months’ imprisonment, though courts frequently resolve such matters with an unconditional apology rather than the maximum sentence, as seen in several recent Supreme Court contempt matters.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is criminal contempt of court?
Under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, criminal contempt covers acts, including words spoken in court, that scandalise or lower the authority of a court, or interfere with judicial proceedings. It is distinct from civil contempt, which deals with disobedience of a court’s order or undertaking.
Why did the case need the Attorney General’s consent?
The law requires that written consent before a private party, such as the Supreme Court Bar Association here, can formally move a criminal contempt petition against someone. Without it, the SCBA’s request could not proceed to a hearing on the merits.



Leave a Reply